Helping ESL and EFL students with difficult English grammar rules and empowering ELTs with ESL worksheets and materials.
Blog Teacher Stumpers Descriptive English Grammar vs Prescriptive English Grammar
Avatar

Descriptive English Grammar vs Prescriptive English Grammar

PDFPrintE-mail
Monday, 01 March 2010 18:34
Written by Neal Chambers

 

Sparky: English grammar is really difficult.
Mr.Maru: Why is that?
Sparky: well, sometimes I read a grammar rule and study it but people don't speak that way.
Mr.Maru: Can you give me an example?
Sparky: Using their, a teacher told me I shouldn't use their for a single person, but people use it all the time.
Mr.Maru: Yes, they/them/their is often used to talk about a single person. Some people do think it is wrong though.
Sparky: Why?
Mr.Maru: There are different kinds of grammar for English you can use - one is descriptive and one is prescriptive.


What is the difference between prescriptive and descriptive grammar? What is descriptive grammar? What is prescriptive grammar? Let's go over some examples and explanations.

descripitive grammarWhat is Descriptive Grammar?

Language is constantly changing. It is a unique organic system that is never static. English has become an important language because it has evolved and adapted over several hundreds of years to become what it is today.

As the language changes the rules for the language change as well. If the majority (50% or more) use the language one way that becomes the new rule. Changes happen slowly because there are over a billion English speakers in the world, but they do still happen.

Descriptive grammar describes how grammar is actually being used. It can also be called colloquial grammar. When speakers start to change the language, descriptive grammar helps to describe what is happening.

For example, using 'they/their/them' to mean 'he or she/his or her/him or her' is a common piece of descriptive grammar. For example,

An individual can update their profile with their name and address.

Another grammar point that is becoming more common is using the verb 'graduate' without 'from'. For example,

I graduated Japan university.
I graduated from Japan university. (standard usage)

Descriptive grammar is important to know because it describes how the language is actually being used. However, it is sometimes considered too casual or incorrect by some. It is not appropriate to use this type of grammar for school papers or business documents.

prescriptive grammarWhat is Prescriptive Grammar?

Prescriptive grammar is more familar to us. This is the type of grammar that is described in most older textbooks and reference books. If you are an ESL/EFL student you have studied these rules in class and drilled sentences with this grammar. If you are a professional writer you have seen these rules in the style guides such as the AP style guide that are in common use.


Prescriptive grammar is usually the safest type of grammar to use. Professors and teachers expect you to use this type of grammar and publishers will require you to use it. Be sure to check the appriopriate guides for your industry.

Where does Prescriptive Grammar Come From?

About 500 years ago, there weren't any grammar rules for English. The same word had several different spellings. There were different regional dialects of English that had their own structure and vocabulary.

William Bullokar wrote one of the first grammars for English in 1578. He also invented a standard alphabet for the English language. This first grammar book was written like the Latin grammar books written during the 16th century. William wanted English to become a widely used language. It had to be accepted by academics and scholars. So, he created rules similar to rules in Latin. Latin was used by academics and religious scholars at that time and it was highly respected. At the same time, English was seen as a common language used by the people and not highly respected.

 

Which is better Descriptive Grammar or Prescriptive Grammar?

This is a difficult question. You must think about your audience (the people reading or listening to you). If your audience is academic or you are writing for business, it's better to use prescriptive grammar. In more casual situations, like emails, friendly chats, or (some) blogs, it's perfectly acceptable to use descriptive grammar

.
What do you think of prescriptive or descriptive grammar? Let me know in the comments below.

Last Updated on Monday, 08 March 2010 13:41
 

Comments  

 
0 #3 re: pardon my English!Neal Chambers 2010-10-24 14:13
Thanks Jaba for the comments,

I made the mistake of not capitalizing university, so the two example sentences should read the following way:

I graduated Japan University.
I graduated from Japan University.

Japan University is, of course, a fictional university. Maybe that was a bad choice of words on my part. Sorry for the confusion!

And thanks for adding the comment about they/their/them, I've never really thought about them that way. It's a good description of their use.
Quote
 
 
+1 #2 Pardon my English !Jaba Dale 2010-10-24 09:44
Hello...I have to disagree with the examples given :

I graduated Japan university.
I graduated from Japan university. (standard usage)

Both these sentences are wrong ! They should read :

I graduated from a Japanese university.

Regarding the use of their / they / them : when we don't know the gender of the person who did something, we use the 3rd person plural to describe the duality of the given situation...simply put, two possibilities force the use of the 3rd person plural. In some cases the "it" may be used i.e. I wonder who it was / could have been ?

Hope this helps !
Quote
 
 
0 #1 RE: Descriptive English Grammar vs Prescriptive English GrammarEnglish Grammar 2010-07-31 06:00
This is really a wonderful article,Grammar is such a vast subject specially for the people's who don't have English as there mother tongue,had able to speak good English but not very good grammar.I always had troubles while using the tenses and even prepositions and i am improving on this..thanks to this article.
Quote
 

Add comment

Anything that is respectful and contributes to the article will be accepted.


Security code
Refresh

rss-green-64

Follow
EnglishSpark

feed-icon-orange-32-desat
Blog
ESL materials
Materials
facebook-hand-drawn-32youtube-hand-drawn-32twitter-hand-drawn-32
Learn English with Free Podcasts

What do you do?

Live Chat by comm100