Helping ESL and EFL students with difficult English grammar rules and empowering ELTs with ESL worksheets and materials.
Students Complex Reported Speech Part 1 - Teacher Stumpers
Avatar

Complex Reported Speech Part 1 - Teacher Stumpers

PDFPrintE-mail
Monday, 15 June 2009 13:39
Written by Neal Chambers

On TV:

Angie: You took my mePhone!
Bob: I will never give you your mePhone back! I need to use Twitter!
Angie: I loved you until you took my mePhone.
Bob: That hurts.

Later, Mr. Maru and Sparky are talking:

Mr. Maru: Did you hear about Bob and Angie?
Sparky: Oh yeah, they are fighting again. She said he took her mePhone.
Mr. Maru: um, he took her mePhone?
Sparky: Yeah, that's right. And he said he would never give her your mePhone back!
Mr. Maru: You mean give her her mePhone back?
Sparky: Mmm, err, yeah. She said she loved him until he took her mePhone.
Mr. Maru: I'm completely confused.
Sparky: Me, too.

Reported speech can be confusing. We use it all the time to report the news or gossip. It is very useful. Let's first go over the basics:

There are two ways to report a person's words or thoughts:

1) We can report it directly:

Bob: I am Bob.

Bob said, "I am Bob."

 

2) We can report it indirectly:

Bob: I am Bob.

Bob said he was Bob.

 

In spoken English, we usually use the second one, indirect speech or reported speech. When we are writing a story, we always use the first one, direct speech. There are a few rules about indirect speech though. It can get very complicated. Let's look at the rules:

 

Change the tense

When we report the words, we have to change the tense of the verb. For example,

Bob: I am Bob.

Bob said he was Bob.

In the above example, 'am' is the present tense of 'to be' and this changes to 'was', the past tense of 'to be.'

We also need to change 'will' to 'would.' For example,

Bob: I will go shopping.

Bob said he would go shopping. (We can say this after Bob went shopping.) OR

Bob said he will go shopping. (We can say this before Bob goes shopping.)

This can be difficult! The same sentence is reported differently at different times:

 

reportedspeech

 

Be careful! You can use both before he goes shopping. 'Bob said he will go shopping.' sounds stronger - Bob WILL go shopping! But, this is a small difference.

 

Let's take a quick quiz:

What did Bob say? (direct speech)

1) Bob said he would go fishing.

A) I will go fishing.

B) He will go fishing.

C) I would go fishing.

 

2) Bob said Angie went shopping too much.

A) Angie went shopping too much.

B) Angie goes shopping too much.

C) We go shopping too much.

 

3) Bob said Angie read comic books.

A) Angie reads comic books.

B) Angie read comic books.

C) Angie had read comic books.

 

Answers

  1. A) or sometimes C) - Angie: Do you want to go fishing? Bob: I would go fishing (if it weren't raining.)

  2. B)

  3. A)

 

Do you have any questions? Please ask me in the comments. Please login and comment, you can earn Kala, or points, you can use in the future. So try it today and earn some Kala!

 

Last Updated on Monday, 29 June 2009 15:01
 

Comments  

 
0 #1 Julian Gilbert 2009-06-17 17:12
The problem with reported speech is that the tenses don't change if what is being reported is still true at the time of the reporting.Therefore the following could all be correct;
Bob said he will go fishing.
Bob said Angie goes shopping too much.
Bob said Angie reads comic books.

The second and third sentences I would even say muststay unchanged, unless Angie has had a change of character and no longer goes shopping too much and reads comic books.
In real life we most often report what is still true so a lot of the time it's unnecessary to change the tenses.
Quote
 

Add comment

Anything that is respectful and contributes to the article will be accepted.


Security code
Refresh

Follow Englishspark

Follow
EnglishSpark

Teacher Stumpers
Blog
ESL materials
Study Tools
facebook-hand-drawn-32youtube-hand-drawn-32twitter-hand-drawn-32
EnglishSpark recommends Learn any language quickly!
Click the image above to start speaking a language from day 1.

What do you do?

Live Chat by comm100